Archibald Douglas, 1st Baron Douglas
(arguably 3rd Marquess of Douglas)


Archibald James Edward Douglas (formerly SteuartArchibald James Edward Douglas [formerly Stewart], first Baron Douglas (1748–1827), litigant and politician, the son of Sir John Stewart of Grandtully, third baronet (1687–1764), and his wife, Lady Jane Douglas (1698–1753), was born on 10 July 1748 at Faubourg St Germain, Paris.


His early life was dominated by the efforts of his parents and supporters to establish his identity as nephew and heir of Archibald Douglas, duke of Douglas (bap. 1694, d. 1761). His mother, the duke's only sister, had in 1746 married without her brother's knowledge Colonel John Stewart, a former Jacobite sympathizer and veteran of the Swedish army, and fled to the continent. Two years later she informed the duke of the marriage and notified him that she was (at the age of fifty) pregnant. Subsequently she reported the birth on 10 July 1748 of twin boys, named Archibald and Sholto(1). The irascible and eccentric duke disapproved of the marriage, cut off his sister's allowance, and—encouraged by the duke of Hamilton's family, who stood next in line to the sister as heir—refused to recognize the twins as hers. In 1751 the family returned to Britain, where they lived a hand-to-mouth existence as Colonel Stewart was soon imprisoned for debt.

Sholto and Lady Jane both died in 1753.


Archibald's upbringing was taken over by Lady Schaw of Greenock, and, after her death in 1757, by the duke and duchess of Queensberry, who saw to his education, first at Rugby School (1759–61) and then at Westminster School (1761–5). The reclusive duke of Douglas surprisingly married in March 1758, and the new duchess, Margaret Douglas of Mains, became an aggressive advocate of Archibald's claim to the Douglas estates, which were said to be worth in excess of £12,000 a year. Before the duke died, she convinced him to reinvestigate the case and to name Archibald as his heir. Following the duke's death in July 1761, Archibald Stewart was duly served heir and took the surname Douglas.

This set the stage for one of the eighteenth century's most famous legal battles, the Douglas cause. Archibald's inheritance was challenged by the Hamiltons, who argued that he and his brother were supposititious. The Hamilton lawyers put together a plausible circumstantial argument that Archibald was actually Jacques Louis Mignon, the son of a Parisian glassworker, who had disappeared in July 1748. The case was litigated at great length and expense (the two sides spent £54,000 between them). It attracted tremendous interest, especially in Scotland. Not only was a large estate at stake, but many felt that requiring Archibald Douglas to in effect prove his identity raised a question that could endanger the security of inheritance in general. In Scotland the Douglas side enjoyed broad popular support, with James Boswell an especially eager partisan, though many of the literati favoured the Hamilton side. In 1767 the court of session decided by the casting vote of the lord president against Douglas. Douglas appealed to the House of Lords which, following the opinions of law lords Mansfield and Camden, reversed the decision without a division.

Douglas settled easily into the life of a landed magnate. He was an improving landlord who continued the rebuilding of Douglas Castle begun by his uncle, though investment in the Ayr bank of Douglas, Heron & Co., which failed in 1772, complicated his finances during the 1770s. He also achieved a degree of political prominence as he worked to resurrect the Douglas interest in Lanarkshire, Berwickshire, Forfarshire, and elsewhere. He was elected member for Forfarshire in 1782, and was made lord lieutenant of the county in 1794. During the following year he raised a regiment of fencibles(2). In parliament he was a loyal, if silent, follower of Henry Dundas and William Pitt, a status that facilitated his successful pursuit of a peerage. Although he would have preferred an earldom, he was created Baron Douglas of Douglas in 1790.

Douglas married twice into ducal families: first, on 13 June 1771, Lady Lucie Graham (1751–1780), daughter of the second duke of Montrose, and second, on 13 May 1783, Lady Frances Scott (1750–1817), sister of the third duke of Buccleuch; among the children born of this second marriage was Caroline Lucy Scott, novelist. Horace Walpole commented that ‘it is proof of his sense, that he can forgive her person in favour of her merit’ (to Lady Ossory, 17 April 1783, Walpole, Corr., 33.399).


He was also the father of George Douglas (1788-1838), Captain in the Royal Navy, and Sholto Scott Douglas (1785-1821), a Captain in the 6th Inniskillen Dragoons at Waterloo.


Douglas died on 26 December 1827 at Bothwell Castle, Lanarkshire. He was buried in Douglas parish church in the same county. Forever identified with the Douglas cause, as an adult he proved a rather unexceptional aristocrat.


(1) It would be assumed that a woman of such advanced years, pregnant for the first time, would take great care and settle down in comfort to await the birth. Lady Jane, however, abruptly moved from Aix-la-Chapelle to Paris in the eighth month of her pregnancy accompanied only by her husband and a maid. Supposedly this was to place her under the care of the best doctors in France. In the end the doctor who delivered the babies could never be found nor could the woman who was purported to have owned the house in which the births took place. 

Even though twins were reported in letters, the couple returned to Rheims in July, 1748 with only one infant. When questioned about the other baby it was said he was left in the care of the doctor. 

It wasn't until November, 1749 that the couple, again in the company of the same maid, returned to Paris to retrieve their son. Interestingly, it was later found that there had been two kidnappings in Paris in that period of time, one in July, 1748 and another in November, 1749. Witnesses claimed, in both cases, that the baby boys were carried off by a Lady, a Gentleman and their maid. This was enough to convince the court, albeit in a very close decision, to award the Douglas properties to the Duke of Hamilton. 

Burns funeral procesion
Robert Burns's funeral procession through Dumfries.

The Royal Dumfries Volunteers, or which Burns was a member, wore blue coats so presumably the Angusshire Regiment are leading.
The arms of Douglas of Douglas on the dexter (left) side of the shield are blazoned: Quarterly: 1, Azure a lion rampant argent crowned with an imperial crown or (Galloway); 2, Or a lion rampant gules surmounted by a ribbon in bend sable (Abernathy); 3, Argent three piles gules (Wishart); 4, Or a fess checky azure and argent surmounted of a bend sable charged with three buckles of (Stewart of Bonkill); overall on an escutcheon Argent a heart gules crowned or on a chief azure three mullets argent (Douglas of that Ilk).

The paternal arms of his wife, Lucy Graham, are blazoned: Quarterly: 1 and 4, Or on a chief sable three escallops or (Graham); 2 and 3, Argent three roses gules (Montrose). 
(2) In 1795, he raised the Angusshire Regiment of Fencible Infantry, who served in Ireland and Dumfries, as well as being involved with founding the Angus Volunteers Company of Fencible Men earlier in the same year. It was the latter Company that where on duty at the funeral of Robert Burns in 1796 (although some references have inaccurately attributed this to the former group). Some sources claim that he was the Colonel of the Forfar and Kincardine Militia in Ireland in 1815.

3.  If the same man, then as Archibald Douglas of Douglas, he was in 1788 recorded as owner of:
• Baxtonlees, another name for Peel in the upper headwaters of the Liddel, near the eastern border of Castleton Parish.
• Lintalee, a house about a mile south of Jedburgh on the banks of the Jed Water and formerly in the Jed Forest.
• Swinnie, a hamlet and farm off the A68 on the B6357 towards Hallrule.
and in 1780, parts of


4.  This death notice puts some of the assumptions about Archibald into question  It is dated 17th January 1804



Birth: 1748

Death: 1827

Father: John (Sir) (3rd of Grandtully) Stewart
Mother: Jane (of Douglas) Douglas b: 17 MAR 1697/98


Marriage 1: Lady Lucy Graham, dau of Duke of Montrose

Archibald Douglas, 2nd Baron Douglas of Douglas   b. 25 Mar 1773, d. 27 Jan 1844
Charles Douglas, 3rd Baron Douglas of Douglas   b. 26 Oct 1775, d. 10 Sep 1848
Jane Margaret Douglas   b. b 1780 married Henry, Lord Montagu, second son of Henry, third Duke of Buccleuch.

Marriage 2: Lady Frances Scott, daughter of Francis Scott, Earl of Dalkeith

Hon. Caroline Lucy Douglas   She married Admiral Sir George Scott on 27 October 1810. She died on 20 April 1857.
Frances Elizabeth Douglas   She married William Moray Stirling in 1826. She died on 14 September 1854. 
Mary Sidney Douglas  She married Robert Douglas in 1821. He died in 1844.  He lived at Strathany.
Hon. Sholto Scott Douglas   b. 1785, d. 1821
Reverend James Douglas, 4th Baron Douglas of Douglas   b. 9 Jul 1787, d. 6 Apr 1857
Hon. George Douglas   He was born on 2 August 1788. He died in 1838, unmarried.

See also:

  • Douglas of Douglas

  • The Douglas cause


    This page was last updated on 23 June 2019

    Click here to 
    Print this page

    Biography finder





























    Index of first names